We’ll provide you with the information you need and the insurance products you require to help make sure you enjoy the full value of the assets and possessions you’ve worked so hard to achieve and maintain. Our goal is to help you protect yourself, your family, your business and your property by advising you about the insurance products best suited to your needs – and then design a comprehensive insurance program tailored to your specific requirements. EQUAL HOUSING LENDER. Member FDIC. Investment and insurance products are not FDIC Insured.
| Friday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Tuesday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Thursday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
511 5th St, Defiance, OH 43512
Great raties
Great Customer Service
insurance done right
awesome have had them for decades
The people is what makes this company better than most.
Rita is wonderful to work with, always responsive, and very helpful!
They couldn’t do nothing for me all there prices were out the roof
customer service is very solid (Amy Biegel)… responsive, detailed, and helpful to explain options
Found me a great deal on car insurance, I paid 1/3 of what was quoted at other places. Unusual I would assume, but great!
Agent AJ Stites comes highly recommended from our business to yours.
AJ and Darby Naton both have great communications, customer service, and concern for their clients. 5 Star
⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Very helpful and service oriented staff. Helped reduce insurance cost by 1,800 per year!
I’ve been with First Insurance for a very very long time, decades it seems. They have always taken care of me and offer the best prices for the most coverage.
Andy, Tim, and Pat are always very responsive with whatever issue arises, whether with policy renewal, policy changes, or God forbid, an insurance claim. That’s why I always give their names whenever someone I know is shopping for a new insurance policy.
I’ve had my business insured through this agency for over 20 years. Here are the 2 major things that have impressed me to the point that I don’t even consider looking for a new supplier: …
I would highly recommend the First Insurance Group to anyone shopping for great rates for all your insurance needs. The staff is always very knowledgeable and friendly.
Been with this company for years. They’ve always looked out for the best rates for me and notify me when they find them. My policy also covers glass. They had my windshield replaced immediately without any adjustments to my rates. Couldn’t ask for better service! Thank you!
Andy has been our agent for 20+ years and has always had our best interest at heart. It think it says a lot when you have the same agent for that long. I highly recommend him and First Insurance Group!
My agent, Matt Karaffa, is always ready and willing to help me with any questions or issues I have regarding insurance for the Rossford Convention & Visitors Bureau. He is knowledgeable and I know I can depend on his expert guidance.
My family have been clients for many years and Lynn has been just beyond helpful! She is always so helpful and pleasant and when my circumstances changed, she went out of her way to get me an amazing rate that matched my needs. So very nice to find this kind of commitment.