Established in 1897, Brethren Mutual Insurance Company is a property-casualty insurer and provides writing for personal, commercial and farm insurance.
| Friday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Tuesday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
| Thursday | 8AM to 4:30PM |
149 N Edgewood Dr, Hagerstown, MD 21740
Called for information answered question right away
Love my agent.
Great company, friendly helpful staff.
CROOKS! They take advantage of the Ederly. Take their money for 20+ years and then drop them when it’s time to pay…CROOKS!
The worst insurance company on the plant !! Pray you never have to deal with these people !
For those of you who are looking for an insurance company do not get involved with this one they are the worst And I really mean it
Had them for one year at a good price . They raised my rates so I left them
Was ran off the road by a truck and had $2500 damage to my vehicle, after the claim they dropped me, after 12 years
Great products and service at a fair price. Very friendly staff as well. Highly recommended!
Brethren Mutual is a great Company with a wonderful staff! Highly recommend!
This company is the biggest scam ever they did not pay for my stolen jewlery even that I had insurance on them stay away from them
Claim process for my auto loss was really smooth. Quick response and settled soon after.
Brethren Mutual is a great company. The staff are very friendly and are always very helpful.
Great customer service! Easy to file and process a claim. Would definitely recommend this company to friends and family.
I have had insurance with this company for many years, nothing but the best service and quality coverages for the money!
I have auto insurance with them, low rates
Ever jump the gun and say things you dont mean? Well thats what happened to me. I got mad and frustrated and took it out on my agent. The whole time she remained professional. Idk if things changed around there or what but my agent was an honest to god professional in every way.
Terrible insurance company my grandmother was backed into, and this was the other parties insurance company. They don’t pick up and they try their best to get out of paying claims. Insurance shoppers beware!
It has been two weeks since one of their insured customers rear ended me, and I still have yet to hear anything about getting my car fixed. I have called daily and they havent heard from the adjuster. I am getting very frustrated.
I’ve been working with Brethren Mutual for 30 years! The company cares about its policyholders and makes sure the customer is taken care of in their time of need.
Brethren Mutual covered our home when no one else would because it
was a manufactured home. We have had our auto and home insurance with them for years with no problems.
If you ever get hurt at work and you find your business uses Brethren Mutual Insurance for Worker’s Compensation: get a lawyer straight away. These people are not your friends. They will not care if another part of you fails as a result of …
They shouldn’t be able to even receive one star. We were passed on the shoulder by one of their “insured customers” they scratched the entire passenger side of our truck, then decided to pull over, then proceed to pull away after 5 minutes …
That’s the second time I went to that website to download my insurance policy. Instead of my plan, I have found someone else plan and address. They’re putting people’s information out there.
I have had nothing but an absolute positive experience with Brethren Mutual. I was recently in an accident with one of their insured and they were nothing but lovely to me and kept me updated the entire time. I called them probably an …
My doublewide on a permanent foundation was insured my them through an agent. When they ended their contract with that agent I had to be reinsured through the new agent and they would not insure my home as real estate and had to be insured …
I have had a bad gut feeling about Bretheren since opening my auto and home policy a couple of years ago. They are not flexible nor accommodating to their clients needs and their underwriting is waaaay too onerous and convoluted. Back and …
Changes to underwriting guidelines no longer allow vehicle to driver ratios over 2:1. They provided 2 months’ notice to find a new insurance company. Their auto rates were never great, but bundled with other policies, they were the best of my options.
22 years with this company. I had 2 cars insured and dropped one from coverage. My premiums went up $120 a payment!! So you get penalized if you only have one car insured. I thought it would go down. Was able to get coverage with another …
I have had my home/auto/umbrella policies for years with Brethren. They are helpful in determining your personal insurance needs. I have no complaints with the services they provide.
Since 1981 Brethren Mutual has been there for us both car and home insurance policies . I must say they are friendly, knowledgeable and have never let us down. Yes, it is possible to find cheaper insurance but is it worth the risk, …
We have always had a wonderful experiences with our broker who represents Brethren Mutual. We have coverage for both our home and 2 cars. When our son was in the process of moving out of the regional coverage area they covered his car …
I have never made a homeowner’s insurance claim in nearly 30 years of home ownership. Always pay my premium in full at the beginning of my renewal period. So Brethren basically gets to bank my money all year. Was six days late (because I …
Brethren Mutual is and has been a quality carrier for many years. They’re local to MD which provides a small company feel rather than a large national insurance company that typically have things like outsourced call centers. Quality coverage with competitive premiums.
This is the worst insurance in the world!!!! We had a accident and they kept coming up with excuses to not pay. When they finely did pay it they informed that we had to get rid of our dog which caused the accident. Even though he had …
Worse insurance company ever! We had water damage under the house because a piped busted and it had to be replaced thought out the house because we live on a slab. John Harris, their agent in Chesapeake, Va has still not sent money back for …
I called Brethren Mutual today regarding an issue and situation I’ve been dealing with about one of my homes. After a brutal force of nature, a tree belonging to a neighboring house toppled onto my property, dealing damage of all kinds to …
I’ve had Brethren Mutual for over 28 years. My insurance was canceled and I wasn’t aware of payment. Because I wasn’t getting all my mail. I was staying at my daughter’s recovering from a total knee replacement. The payment was due Nov.15 …
Why can’t I give 0 stars? Had a fender bender. My agent for Brethen told me I had accident forgiveness so I would not be charged. Brethen came back a full year later and changed their minds, charging me with the accident?!?! What kind of …
The ABSOLUTE WORST insurance company I’ve ever dealt with. They raise our insurance every year with no tickets, claims or accidents. Our homeowners has went up 100.00 more every year. I’m done with this fly by night company, they’re the …